how to soften hard plumbers putty

"Softening Hard Plumber's Putty: Easy Tricks You Can Try Today"

By Jessica White
AD

If you're a homeowner or a DIY enthusiast, you've probably encountered plumber's putty at some point. This versatile, low-cost material is a must-have for creating watertight seals around sink drains, faucets, and other plumbing fixtures. However, over time, plumber's putty can harden and lose its flexibility, making it difficult to work with. In this guide, we'll explore how to soften hard plumbers putty, ensuring you can always maintain a perfect seal.

Understanding Plumber's Putty

Plumber's putty is a versatile, non-hardening, non-drying, and non-shrinking material made from a combination of linseed oil, clay, and other fillers. Its primary function is to create a watertight seal between two surfaces. While it's designed to remain flexible, prolonged exposure to air and heat can cause it to harden and become less pliable.

Why Does Plumber's Putty Harden?

Plumber's putty hardens due to a process called oxidation. When the putty is exposed to air, the linseed oil in it begins to oxidize, causing the putty to lose its flexibility and become hard. Heat can also accelerate this process. Understanding why putty hardens is crucial because it helps us determine the best methods to soften it.

AD
How to Remove Plumbers Putty
How to Remove Plumbers Putty
How to Use Plumbers Putty on a Bathroom Sink Drain | Homesteady
How to Use Plumbers Putty on a Bathroom Sink Drain | Homesteady
Plumbers Putty How to Use It for Plumbing Projects
Plumbers Putty How to Use It for Plumbing Projects

How to Soften Hard Plumber's Putty

Method 1: Warm Water Soak

The most common and effective method to soften hard plumber's putty is to soak it in warm water. Here's how to do it:

  • Remove the hardened putty from the fixture. If it's stuck, you may need to use a putty knife or a flathead screwdriver to gently pry it off.
  • Place the putty in a bowl of warm water. Ensure the putty is completely submerged.
  • Let it soak for about 15-30 minutes. The warm water will help to rehydrate the putty and make it more pliable.
  • After soaking, gently knead the putty with your fingers or roll it into a snake-like shape. If it's still too hard, let it soak for a bit longer.

Once the putty is soft enough, you can use it to create a new seal. Remember, it's best to use the putty within a few hours of softening to prevent it from hardening again.

How to Use Plumber's Putty | Repair and Replace
How to Use Plumber's Putty | Repair and Replace
How To Clean Durham's Rock Hard Water Putty
How To Clean Durham's Rock Hard Water Putty
How to Remove Plumbers Putty
How to Remove Plumbers Putty

Method 2: Linseed Oil

If the warm water method doesn't work, you can try softening the putty with linseed oil. Here's how:

  • Remove the hardened putty from the fixture.
  • Place the putty in a bowl and pour a small amount of linseed oil over it. Ensure the putty is completely coated.
  • Let it sit for about 30 minutes to an hour. The linseed oil will help to rehydrate the putty and make it more pliable.
  • After soaking, gently knead the putty with your fingers or roll it into a snake-like shape. If it's still too hard, let it soak for a bit longer.

Linseed oil can make your hands oily, so you might want to wear gloves during this process. Also, linseed oil can stain surfaces, so be sure to protect your work area with a drop cloth or newspaper.

AD

Method 3: Cheese Grater

If the putty is only slightly hardened, you can try softening it using a cheese grater. Here's how:

Plumbers Putty
Plumbers Putty
Plumbers Putty or Teflon Tape?
Plumbers Putty or Teflon Tape?
Plumbers Putty
Plumbers Putty
Plumbers Putty vs Silicone: What to use and when (June 2026)
Plumbers Putty vs Silicone: What to use and when (June 2026)
Extend Working Time with Durham's
Extend Working Time with Durham's
Replacing a Bathroom Faucet and Drain - All About The House
Replacing a Bathroom Faucet and Drain - All About The House
  • Remove the hardened putty from the fixture.
  • Grate the putty using a cheese grater. The friction from the grater will help to soften the putty.
  • Knead the grated putty with your hands to ensure it's evenly softened.

This method is not suitable for heavily oxidized putty, as it may not be soft enough to grate.

Preventing Plumber's Putty from Hardening

While knowing how to soften hard plumber's putty is useful, it's even better to prevent it from hardening in the first place. Here are some tips:

AD
  • Use it quickly: Once you've opened a package of plumber's putty, use it as soon as possible. The longer it's exposed to air, the more likely it is to harden.
  • Store it properly: If you can't use the putty immediately, store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator. This will help to slow down the oxidation process.
  • Keep it cool: Heat can accelerate the hardening process, so try to keep your putty in a cool place.

By following these tips, you can help ensure that your plumber's putty remains soft and pliable, ready to create a watertight seal whenever you need it.

How To Remove Plumber’s Putty? - 5 Tips To Consider » Residence Style
How To Remove Plumber’s Putty? - 5 Tips To Consider » Residence Style
“silicone” INSTEAD of “plumbers putty” on kitchen drain basket
“silicone” INSTEAD of “plumbers putty” on kitchen drain basket
How To Use Plumber's Putty
How To Use Plumber's Putty
Homemade Cleaning Putty
Homemade Cleaning Putty
Softening Hard, Dry Wood Putty in Minutes
Softening Hard, Dry Wood Putty in Minutes
DIY Cleaning Putty
DIY Cleaning Putty
Drying time for Durham's® Water Putty
Drying time for Durham's® Water Putty
Easy DIY tips from a Professional Plumber
Easy DIY tips from a Professional Plumber
Water Putty vs Bondo: Which Is Better? - Durham's Rock Hard Water Putty
Water Putty vs Bondo: Which Is Better? - Durham's Rock Hard Water Putty
Tips to Install a Bathroom Faucet | The DIY Playbook
Tips to Install a Bathroom Faucet | The DIY Playbook
Tips on Sanding Durham's Water Putty
Tips on Sanding Durham's Water Putty
This Soap and Toothpaste Trick Fixes a Big Problem! #cleaning
This Soap and Toothpaste Trick Fixes a Big Problem! #cleaning
DIY Cleaning Putty
DIY Cleaning Putty
Simple Plumbing Problems You Can Fix Before Calling a Professional
Simple Plumbing Problems You Can Fix Before Calling a Professional

In the world of DIY plumbing, knowing how to soften hard plumber's putty is a valuable skill. Whether you're a seasoned handyman or a first-time DIYer, understanding how to work with this versatile material can save you time, money, and frustration. So the next time you find yourself with a batch of hardened putty, don't despair - with these methods, you can bring it back to life and create a perfect seal.

AD